Dana Louise Ward 28/02/2005
Literature Review of Ritualistic Care in Practice
The purpose of this essay is to validate the use of evidence based practice via constructing a literature review of ritualistic care in practice. Literature may be obtained from various sources for example books, Internet, articles, and research.
The most up to date literature is found in the form of relevant and valid nursing research. Research is important source of information for the nursing profession because it is critical and valid to the development and refinement of knowledge in order to enhance practice. Nursing research can be defined as the systematic objective process of analysing phenomena of importance to nursing (Earlene, 2001). Many articles indicate that a gap exists between research/theory and practice. This is due to a number of different factors such as lack of research, lack of access to research, barriers placed by staff etc. To reduce this gap the approach of evidence-based practice has been introduced (Rolfe 1998, Upton 1999). Evidence based practice can be defined “as an approach to problem-solving in clinical practice” (Roseburg and Donald 1995) or the” systematic interconnecting of scientifically generated evidence with the tacit knowledge of the expert practitioner to achieve a change in a particular practice for the benefit of a well defined client/patient group” (French, 1999). Within literature multiple definitions of the term evidence based practise exist as they do for many other nursing terms (Upton, 1999).
Evidence based practice originated from evidence based medicine which was defined by Sackett (1996, pg 71) as the “ conscientious, explicit, and judicious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients” the term was developed to teach medical students. Evidence based medicine then developed into evidence based heath care, which is an even broader term than evidence based medicine and can be defined as the conscientious use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients or the delivery of health services. Evidence based practice is even more wide-ranging term.
The major justification for evidence-based practice within nursing is to improve patient care. Other benefits of evidence-based practice include demonstration of effectiveness, justify skill mix, problem solving, identifying needs, provides a rationale for practice, provides consistent information, enhances professional status and to show purchases the use of evidence based practice (le May, 1999).
Strategies to enhance evidence-based practice include research-based articles, the internet, computer, conferences, journal clubs, motivation, research centres, workshops, databases, lectures, meetings, funding for courses, study days, articles, books, more good quality valid research, in all areas of practice, as well as additional understanding of evidence based practice.
Obstacles which may hinder the utilization of research / change / utilization within practice may includes time, resources, pressure of work, to much change, nursing colleagues being uncooperative, medical staff blocking implementation, implementation may require resourcing, other professions may think research is sub-standard, inability to access research, insufficient skills in critical appraisal, language of research make it inaccessible, lack of motivation, fear, resistance to change, ritualised practice, beliefs that research wont make a difference, research data is not relevant, current practice is ok as it is, (le May, 1999). With regard to the topic chosen, some obstacles, which may hinder change, included people’s beliefs that the old way it is the best way, or this is the way it has always been done. However ritualised practice/care is believed to be an obstacle in itself. Parker (1999) believes that the persistence of ritualistic care is due to the lack of familiarity with research.
Ritualistic action can be defined as carrying out a task without thinking it through in a problem-solving logical way, therefore ritualistic practice could be interpreted as carrying out a care/practice without thinking it through in a problem-solving logical way (Philipin, 2002). Ritual practice has been described as irrational unscientific, unsafe, and repetitive (Philipin 2002, Geffrey 1997, Biley 1997). Although there is view points which, regard rituals as valuable such as the anthropologists. The negative side of ritualistic care is talked about more, and usually brings areas of practice/care into light, what need additional valid up to date research.
In Wash and Ford (1989) classic text they called for a “drive for the replacement of ritualised practice”. Later in 1994, Ford and Walsh stated that lack of an in-depth theoretical framework leaves nursing vulnerable to ritualistic practice.
Strange (2002) perceives ritual practice as economically unproductive and primitive. Therefore presenting a disapproving view of ritualistic practice/care.
This negative approach to ritualistic practice is thought to have originated from the fact that we are a technical society and so turn from primitive practice and the fact that irrational is often linked with emotion, which is not scientific.
Negative examples of ritualistic care/practice can be seen throughout clinical practice and these are often task based. Several examples of care that have been termed ritualistic, which will be reviewed in more detail include pre-operative fasting, pressure sore care, observation and drug rounds.
Excessive pre-operative fasting has long been recognised a ritualistic practice even as early as 1883 when Joseph Baron Lister said ‘while it is desirable the there should be no mater in the stomach when chloroform is administered, it will be very salutary to give a cup of beef tea about two hours previously’ (Jester, 1999). However preoperative fasting was not always carried out as it was only made mandatory in practice after Mendelson’s lamark study in 1946 before which a drink was often recommended before the procedure (Greenfield, 1997) Pre-operative fasting is believed to eliminate the risk of vomiting/gastric aspiration during induction which may lead to complications which could be fatal (O’Callagham, 2002). O’Callagham (2002) states that it is a ‘medical and legal requirement that a patient must not be anathetised without a period of fasting from food and fluids, except in emergency surgery’. The length of time, which a patient should be fasted from fluids and food, is still controversial as it takes variable amounts of time for the stomach to empty depending on what is what is eaten and what is drank. Walsh and Ford (1989) found that patients were ritualistically starved from anything from 8 to 20 hours and deemed it as unthinking and irrational as research shows that fasting time would cause no harm be 4-8 hours for food and 2 hours for clear fluid (Philps 1993, Morris 2002). In the case of solid food Nimmo et al (1983) cited in Walsh and Ford (1989) found that a light meal of toast had 2-3 hours before surgery had no effect. Also Chapman (1996) Hung (1992) Maltby (1993) cited in Jester (1999) demonstrated that it was safe for patients to have food 6-8 hours before surgery. In the case of clear fluids Agarwel et al (1986) cited in O’Callagham (2002) demonstrated that patient who drank 150ml of water prior to surgery had lowered gastric volumes that patients who had fasted since midnight. Also the amount of saliva swallowed would be more that a small drink of water. Starvation for vast periods of time can be uncomfortable and source of increase stress (Walsh and Ford, 1989). Apart from being uncomfortable it could also put the elderly at risk of dehydration and confusion, which may in turn lead to the operation being cancelled (Jester, 1999). In addition vomiting after surgery is usually due to drinking to soon following surgery, patients who have drunk within a few hours of induction of anathesia should be less thirsty post-operatively and try not to drink to soon (Smith, 1997). There sufficient knowledge that preoperative fasting is a classic example of ritualistic practice that the days of nil by mouth at midnight should be drawing to a end (Morris, 2002) and patients fasting times should be calculated individually. Although Biley (1997) says that the pre-operative fast is part of the hospital process and so not having as long may make experienced patients of hospital life, feel like they are excluded.
Fabricius Hildanus first described for the clinical characteristics of pressure sores in 1593 (Defloor, 1999). Pressure sores be defined as “lesions on any skin surface that occur from unrelieved pressure and result in damage to underlying tissue” (Schultz 1999 pg 434). The factors, which influence pressure sores, can be split in to intrinsic and extrinsic factors. Intrinsic factors include nutritional status, mobility, and vascular status. Extrinsic factors include pressure, moisture, friction and shearing (Thoroddsen, 1999). Pressures sore care/treatment has come along way in the last 20 years. There is a great deal of research, which has been done on the prevention of pressure sores. However the majority of this research is funded by company’s, which sell mattresses or creams therefore is probable that the research may have an element of bias.
Over the last 20 years numerous methods, which have been deemed ritualistic (unthinking) have been utilized to treat pressure sores. The methods have included using meths, oils, which according to Anthony (1987) cited in Walsh and Ford (1989) promotes breakdown of the skin by destroying normal flora therefore helping infection and skin necrosis. Other preventative measures that have also been used in the past also include talcum powder, creams and rubbing/massaging the skin for better circulation. These methods have not shown to reduce incidence of pressure sores and may have caused harm. The simplest way to prevent pressure sores is to remove the pressure. Exton-Smith (1987) conducted a study in a 100 at risk which patients were turned every 2 hours; the result was a reduction from a 19% incidence to a 4 % incidence of pressure sores. This is study show’s a more evidence based/rational method than ritualistic method used in the past. However ritualistic practice is still seen in practice relating to pressure sore prevention as friction is a cause of pressure sores and even though it is not allowed draglifts that create friction are still being done with patients. As mentioned before the special mattresses are usually rippled and are believed to relieve the incidence of pressure sores. However there are so many companies with different beds and each company says there bed is the best at preventing pressure sores that it is hard to know which is best. Exton-Smith (1987) indicates that these beds are only affective, if lying down. When a patient has been lying flat in practice I have observed 2 turning sheets with a blanket over the special mattress left under the patient this must reduce the preventative affect of the mattress. This ritualistic use of a turning sheet was a common occurrence.
If a pressure sore does develop then healing needs to commence. Walsh and Ford (1989) have found that pressure sores are often treated differently from other wounds, however if they were treated the same care would be more rationale. In the past piped oxygen and egg whites have been used to heal pressure sores. Today a more rationale treatment is practiced. The state of the pressure sore would determine the treatment, which the tissue viability nurse would recommend.
Observations are another ritualistic time consuming practice, which persists. The frequency of which observations e.g. temperature, blood pressure, pulse, respiratory rate need’s to be taken into account to not be termed ritualistic or a waste of nurse’s time depends for each individual.
Temperature is a normal part of the immune response. Therefore temperature is one of the signs/symptoms of the presence of infection. Patient’s temperatures may be taken anything from every 4 hours to twice a day. However it is believed that it is a waste of time to take the temperature of apyrexial patients more than once unless the nurse observes other signs. Samples et al (1983) studied 107 patients by monitoring their temperature over a 24hour period. They found that temperature has a natural cycle which peaks around 18.00 and so concluding that it would be enough to record temp at 18.00 only unless illness was suspected. However Biley (1997) states that having the ritual of temperature being taken despite no pathological reason for the action perhaps might result in greater feelings of empowerment and so enhance self-healing.
Additionally often when blood pressure is taken it is ritualistically taken as definitively correct event though the choice of arm can affect blood pressure as seen in a study by Kristensen (1982) cited in Walsh and Ford (1989) indicated that in 197 men and women 49% had differences in systolic blood pressure of greater than 10mmHg and 29% had differences between diastolic blood pressure. Also the position of the arm can affect blood pressure Webb (1980) cited in Walsh and Ford (1989) found that small movement of the arm up or down from heart level can raise and lower blood pressure between 5-6mmHg. Like temperature, blood pressure is often carried out regularly, and may possibly be a waste of nurse’s time.
Regarding the taking of the pulse a ritual that often happen is the taking of the pulse for 15 seconds then multiplication by 4 to represent the pulse rate for sixty seconds.
Respiratory rate is even more ritually neglected than pulse rate as it is usually not counted at all and the number 20 is automatically written down which is odd as the normal resting respiratory rate is between 12-18.
Drug rounds are seen as ritualistic practice due to the fact that the drug round has been around for along time and does not tend to represent individualised patient centred care, as the nurse if often not familiar with the patient. The drug round is a task-orientated ritual. The sight of a nurse with a trolley of drugs is a common sight. As well as the drugs left on the locker or table for the patient to take later. Also the nurse will ritually give patients their drugs with out explaining what they are and explaining the side effects. Furthermore nurses may not be familiar with the patients for whom they are giving drugs therefore it is not patient centred. In addition the drug round does not leave the nurse room to monitor a patient for side effects.
Anthropology (the study of the human race, its culture and society and its physical development) can assist nursing in understanding the reasons and functions of ritual (Strange, 2001). Anthropologist’s perspective on ritual is that it is “those aspects of prescribed and repetitive formal behaviour which have no direct technological consequences and which are symbolic” (Philipin, 2002, pg 148). Anthropologist and nursing literature also suggest that one of the purposes of ritual is the protection from anxiety for example drawing on ritual in situations where control is lacking. Another purpose more in anthropological literature is that ritual serves to maintain social order via reinforcing cultural and social structure. Both of these purposes are interrelated as protection from anxiety is achieved through the maintenance, of imposition of social order.
Most of the research and literature on this topic is quite old for example Walsh and Ford’s (1989) classic text, which all articles on the topic quote. Also the research on the topic is very limited. However there is a vast amount of knowledge in the articles/books what do exist. Although due to them being old there is uncertainty on what information contained within is out of date and still valid.
The majority of research within the topic chosen reflects practice which is unscientific/unthinking in practice so hopefully it will reflect areas of nursing practice, which needs more research, to improve care practices.
My experience with the topic ritualistic care/practice on placement was regarding care of the elderly. Ritualistic care that I observed was with incontinence pads, which were put on patients even though many patients did not need them. Other ritualistic aspect of care that I noticed was regarding meal times, which were very rushed and very chore like. Drug rounds patients did not know what drugs they had and what they were for, rather they knew the colour of the pills. Also on many occasion I observed heals and buttocks being rubbed for circulation, this must cause friction and friction is a known cause of pressure sores. Also bed times were also ritualualised as everybody was woken up and dressed and washed before breakfast and around 6.00pm staff began to be put patients to bed.
The general consensus on ritualistic care in practice is that there is a lot of practices that are not evidence-based and therefore irrational/ritualistic. However even though there are numerous articles reproving of ritual practice are seen repeatedly ritualistic practice still persists (Strange 2001). This is most likely due to the numerous obstacles put before evidence-based practice. The obstacles that stop evidence based learning are the ones, which help ritualistic practice persist.
The best/only way for ritualistic practice to become evidence-based is by making research/evidence based practice the new ritual.
References
Agarwel, A. et al. (1989) Fluid Deprivation Before Operation – The Effect of a Small Drink. Anaesthesia. Volume 44 No 8. 632-634.
Anthony, D. (1987) Are you in the dark? Nursing Times. Volume 83 No 34 pp 25 – 30.
Biley, F. Wright, S. (1997) Towards a Defence of Nursing Routine and Ritual. Journal of Clinical Nursing. Volume 6. pp 115 – 119.
Chapman, A (1996) current theory and Practice: a study of pre-operative fasting. Nursing Standard. Volume 10 No18. pp 33 – 36.
Defloor, T. (1999) The Risk of Pressure Sores: A Conceptual Scheme. Journal of Clinical Nursing Volume 8 Issue 2. p 206
Earlene, M. (2001) Understanding Research 2nd ed. Nursing Health and Health Care Perspectives. Volume 22 No. 1 p36.
Exton-Smith, N. (1987) The Patients Not for Turning, Nursing Times. Volume No 42.
pp 42 – 4.
Ford, P. Walsh, M. (1994) New Rituals For Old, Nursing Through the Looking Glass. Oxford. Butterworth-Heinmann Ltd.
French, P. (1999) The Development of Evidence Based Nursing. Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 29 No. 1 pp 72-78.
Greenfield, S. Webster, G. Vicary, F. (1997) Drinking Before Sedation. British Medical Journal. Volume 314 page 162
Geffrey, M. (1998) Ritual Action and its Effect on the Nurse as an Advocate. Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 2 No. 1 pp189-194
Hung, P. (1992) Pre-operative Fasting. Nursing Times Volume 88. pp 57 – 60.
Jester, R. Williams, S. (1999) Preoperative Fasting Putting Research into Practice. Nursing Standard. Volume 13 No. 39. pp 33 – 35.
Kristensen, B, O. (1982). Which Arm to Measure Blood Pressure. Scand (suppl) 69-73.
le May, A. (1999) Evidence Based Practice. London. Emap Healthcare Ltd.
Maltby, JR. (1990) New Guidelines for Preoperative Fasting. Canadian Journal of Anaesthesia. Volume 40 No 5. pp 113 –117.
Morris, C. (2002) Prolonged Pre-operative Fasting. Anaesthesia. Volume 57. p 406.
Nimmo, W et al (1983) Gastric Contents at Induction of Anaesthesia is a 4 Hour Fast Necessary? British Journal of Anaesthesiology. Volume 55. pp 1185 – 7
O’Callaghham, N. (2002) Pre-operative Fasting. Nursing Standard. Volume 16 No 36 pp 33 – 37.
Parker, L. (1999) Ritual or Reason. Nursing Times Volume 95 No.20.
Philipin, S. (2002) Rituals and Nursing, A Critical Commentary. Nursing Theory and Concept Development or Analysis. Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 38 No. 2 pp 144.
Philips, H. Hutchinson, S. Davidson, T. (1993) Preoperative Drinking does not Effect Gastric Contents. British Journal of Anaesthesia. Volume 70 No. 1 pp 6 – 9.
Rolfe, G. (1998) The Theory Practice Gap In Nursing From Research-Based-Practice To Practitioner-Based Research. Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 28 No. 3 pp 672 – 679.
Rosenburg, W. Donald, A. (1995) Evidence Based Medicine: An Approach To Clinical Problem Solving. British Medical Journal. Volume 310. pp 1122 – 1126.
Sackett, D. (1996) Evidence Based Medicine: what it is and what it isn’t. British Medical Journal. Volume 312. pp 71-72.
Samples, J et al. (1983) Circadian Rhythms Basis for Screening for Fever. Nursing Research. Volume 34. pp 377 – 9.
Schultz, A. (1999) Etiology and Incidence of Pressure Ulcers in Surgical Patients. AORN Journal. Volume 70 No 3. pp 434, 437 – 440, 443 – 444, 446 – 449.
Smith, A. Vallance, H. Slater, R. (1997) Shorter Preoperative Fluid Fasts Reduce Postoperative Emesis. British medical Journal. Volume 314. p1486.
Strange, F. (2001) The Persistence of Ritual in Nursing Practice. Clinical Effectiveness in Nursing Volume 5. pp 177 – 183.
Thomas E. A. (1987) Pre- operative Fasting: a Question of Routine. Nursing Times. Volume 82 No10. pp 64 – 8.
Thoroddsen, A. (1999) The Principles of Pressure Sore Prevention. Nursing Standard. Volume 13 No 36. pp 46 – 47.
Tonuma, M. Winbolt, M. (2000) From Ritual to Reason Creating an Environment that allows Nurses to Nurse. International journal of Nursing Practice. Volume 6 Issue 4 p214.
Upton, D. (1999) How Can We Achieve Evidence Based Practice If We Have a Theory Practice Gap in Nursing Today? Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 29 No 3. pp 549 – 555.
Walsh, M. Ford, P. (1989) Nursing Rituals, Research and Rational Actions. Oxford. Butterworth-Heinmann Ltd.
Webb, C, H. (1980). The Measurement of Blood Pressure. Primary care. Volume 7, No 4.
Bibliography
Blunt, J. (2001) Wound Cleansing: Ritual or Research Based Practice. Nursing Standard Volume 16 No.1 pp 33 – 36.
Chapmann, G. (1983) Ritual and Rational Actions in Hospitals. Journal of Advanced Nursing. Volume 8. pp13 -2 0.
Conyers V. (1995) Changing ritualistic practice. Contemporary Nurse. Volume 4 No 2. pp 89 – 90.
Mockridge, J. Anthony< D. (1999) Nurses’ knowledge about pressure Sore Treatment and Healing. Nursing Standard. Volume 13 no. 29. pp 69-70.
Tonuma, M. Winbolt, M. (2000) From Ritual to Reason Creating an Environment that allows Nurses to Nurse. International journal of Nursing Practice. Volume 6 Issue 4 p214.
Word Count
Not including end text references and Bibliography = 2789
![order now](https://nursinghomeworkhelps.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/order-now.jpg)